Grumbles about Garrisons

Don’t get me wrong, Blizzard most definitely had me at “Mage Tower” but there is a distinct hum of rebellion in the air.

library

If Garrisons are going to be such a part of our new lives on Draenor, then we need to love the aesthetics. My first character was a Human, a Warlock with a temper which belied her innocent bovine smile but she’s been the only Human I’ve managed to get anywhere near the level cap. My last attempt, a Paladin languishes in the Redridge Inn picking flowers and wondering what she did wrong. I play Gnomes, Elves, Dead Humans, Orcs, Aliens with hooves, anything in fact apart from Humans and yet, it’s Human architecture being forced upon me even on a brave new world.

We knew we wanted the Garrison to feel like a big new feature, but we also wanted to keep it familiar, like bringing a piece of home to Draenor. There is just something about running into Stormwind or Orgrimmar that evokes that sense of faction pride

(From here).

Yes I have an idea of just how unreasonable it would be ask the development teams to create unique artwork for every building but then why couldn’t certain buildings reflect different races? For example the Jewelcrafting one could be based on something Draenic and for the Alliance, your flower garden could take on a Night Elfish feel. You’d still have the same number of buildings to design but it would allow those of us who aren’t particularly keen on granite, stone and wood (or spikes and red banners for the Horde) to have a tiny place to call home in this savage world.

We (or at least I) already have a clear idea of where my characters reside and whilst I know that the Garrisons are meant to be front line encampments on dangerous and foreign soil, so that things like Mentzelia’s home from home as shown below really wouldn’t work, it’s hard to shake free from those ideas.

WoWScrnShot_021514_152217

My second and perhaps more serious concern stems from beginning to realise just how important these Garrisons are going to be. I hate being told what to do. The second someone strongly suggests I should carry out a specific course of action my hackles come up and the pig-tailed brat masquerading as a devil on my shoulder sticks out her tongue. I must admit it surprises most people that I manage to work for an organisation very much into hierarchy but what I don’t think they (including my boss) actually realize is that 99 percent of the time I do what I want. Luckily this currently mirrors official policy fairly closely so my inability to follow anything which sounds like an order isn’t particularly obvious. Show me a line and my automatic response is to cross it so yes, perhaps a chunk of this is motivated by the fact it’s not going to be optional like the farms.

I’m also not a great fan of single player content in WoW and I can’t quite shake the concern that if questing and leveling is linked so thoroughly to your Garrison then this will play a part. I really didn’t enjoy the single person scenarios leading the story line on the Isle of Thunder for example, primarily because doing them as a undergeared healer hurt. Of course the obvious response to that would be “spec damage” but at the end of the day, being forced into a spec you don’t enjoy playing takes the fun out of something just as much as struggling to do it because you hit like a wet kitten. I rarely play alone and certainly when it comes to leveling up through an expansion, that’s definitely something me and Mr Harpy do together. However we’re both interested in different things, he’d like his Alliance garrison to be covered in spikes and dripping with the blood of people silly enough to come around to borrow the sugar. I want gardens and a little bridge over the river. I want a wreath on the door and somewhere to reflex, whereas he’s more likely to spend the minimum amount of time he can there because unless you can grow your own Horde to kill… he’d rather be out in the “real” world.

Am I being negative? Sure I am. I have a chest infection and a tendency to think the worse at all times, it’s part of my coping mechanism. I want to love the Garrisons because they have Mage Towers full of books and a garden but that’s also tainted by doubt. Perhaps it will be just like that other game with a Mage Tower in it, I start out determined to do one thing whether that’s not date Alistair or not love Garrisons and the opposite happens… who knows.

Screenshot20140416222157039

This is definitely not a portent of things to come!

One thing likely to win me over is customisation. The devil is in the details. Give me a tiny Hearthstone board and NPCs playing it in my Inn because I play Hearthstone sometimes. Let me grow some plants for artistic value rather than their ability to be grinded into potions. Give us the chance to reflect a tiny part of our character’s personality, not just in things like the mounts in the stables and what battle pets we have lying around in the shade but in the books, trinkets and followers we have.

 

 

 

About these ads

10 Responses

  1. I’d been thinking the same thing about different buildings reflecting a different race’s sensibilities so that our Garrisons might actually feel like Horde or Alliance Garrisons instead of Human or Orc ones. Why cant our enchanting tower be Blood Elven on Horde Side? Why can’t our herb garden have a tauren flair. It really would make more sense to me. As you said it would take a lot of resources to make a set for each race, but making it a hodge podge of racial designs would feel very fitting.
    And I’m iffy about how I feel about how much of the experience it may be part of. That’s something I’m going to hold off judgement on until it’s actually live and I can see it, but I like playing with other people too and it’s no fun when half of your evening is spent doing solo stuff so you -can- play together.

    • I’m definitely holding judgement too. It will be interesting to see it once we hit beta and more information starts to come out.

  2. We are sisters in spirit. If you absolutely DON’T want me to do something insist I MUST do it. Amazing my family has never taken advantage of this.

    There are many things I’m reading about Warlords that make me worry like side quests not having quest text, kind of kicked to the side of the road as it were. I’m going to try to wait and see. But they better not try to make me churn butter or something at my garrison cause I won’t!

    • Actually that’s an awesome idea, Tome! For cooking: a butter-churning minigame, a dough-kneading minigame, a…a…pot-stirring minigame?

      Just imagine the possibilities!

    • In a way I wish we weren’t being presented with so much data. I can’t not read it because I know it’s there but .,…. maybe not knowing until you’re actually playing would be the best thing for people like me.

  3. As a person who vehemently hates the farm for no real logical reason, the notion that garrisons are compulsory has the hipster in me horrified. I can’t -possibly- be a part of something that everyone else is doing! On a more serious note, I’ve never really given a toss about player housing in any MMO, so I don’t like the notion that it’s going to be essential to game play at all. Now, if I can pimp it out in bright pink unicorn stuff, then maybe, MAYBE, I’ll be interested… :P

    Get well soon!

    • I like the idea of player housing but only if I can make look the way I want, having the exact same decorations as every other Alliance player just wouldn’t work for me and I think that’s part of the issue. They’re going so far but not far enough in that direction.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,334 other followers

%d bloggers like this: